Amish Grace

Willow Geer

Judith

Matt Letscher

Gideon Graber

Tammy Blanchard

Amy Roberts

Kimberly Williams-Paisley

Ida Graber

Bob Rumnock

Reporter

Gary Graham

Henry Taskey

Fay Masterson

Jill Green

Bruce Nozick

Leonard

Eugene Byrd

Danny

Jim Metzler

Sheriff

Sammy Jack

Knepp Boy #1

Darcy Rose Byrnes

Rebecca Knepp

Karley Scott Collins

Katie Graber

Madison Mason

Levi Brennaman

Madison Davenport

Mary Beth Graber

Amy Sloan

Rachel Knepp

Christopher Curry

Minister

Kate Fuglei

Shelly

John Churchill

Charlie Roberts

Taylor Ann Thompson

Hannah

Eric Nenninger

State Trooper

Chloe Madison

Sarah Knepp

David Mazouz

Andy Roberts

Emilee Wallace

Teacher Ruth

Jessica Dickey

Melinda

Trevor Thompson

Jacob

Dale Wade Davis

Rachel's Husband

Joel Schmidt

Melinda's Husband

David Curtis

Amish Elder

Gabriel Welch

Knepp Boy #2

Elijah Tadros

Ryan Roberts

Caleb Babcock

Schoolboy (uncredited)

Daphne Blunt

Lilly (uncredited)

Isabella Interian

Lydia (uncredited)

Marcus Shultz

Knepp Teenager (uncredited)

Johnny Wilson

Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)